Copycat Trader Joe’s Vanilla Bean Paste Recipe

20

With its rich, creamy flavor and those delightful specks of real vanilla beans, this Trader Joe’s Vanilla Bean Paste has quickly become my go-to for elevating desserts, baked goods, and even beverages!

How to make Trader Joe’s Vanilla Bean Paste

Trader Joe’s Vanilla Bean Paste is a baking ingredient made from concentrated vanilla extract combined with ground vanilla bean seeds. Unlike regular vanilla extract, which is liquid, this paste has a thicker, syrup-like consistency and contains visible specks of real vanilla bean.

Ingredients

To make homemade Trader Joe’s Vanilla Bean Paste, you’ll need:

• Vanilla beans (6-8 high-quality pods, ideally Madagascar or Bourbon vanilla).
• Vanilla extract (½ cup for additional flavor depth).
• Sugar (⅓ cup or adjust to taste depending on your recipes). You can substitute this with honey or maple syrup for a unique flavor.
• Water (3 tablespoons, for thinning the paste as needed).
• Thickener (1 teaspoon of cornstarch or xanthan gum). This helps achieve the thick, paste-like consistency.

Instructions

Prepare the Vanilla Beans

1. Cut each vanilla bean lengthwise to split it open. Scrape out the seeds (also called “caviar”) using the back of a knife.
2. Set the scraped seeds aside. Don’t discard the empty pods—they’ll add more flavor later!

Blend the Paste

1. In a food processor or blender, combine the vanilla bean seeds, sugar (or sweetener of choice), vanilla extract, and water. Blend until smooth.
2. Add the empty vanilla pods into the mix and blend again to infuse maximum flavor. (If desired, you can strain the mixture afterward to remove pod debris.)

Thicken the Mixture

1. Transfer the mixture to a small saucepan. Simmer over low heat, stirring frequently, for about 3-5 minutes.
2. Sprinkle the cornstarch or xanthan gum into the saucepan while stirring to thicken the paste to your desired consistency. Add more water if it feels too thick.

Cool and Store

1. Once the paste has cooled, pour it into an airtight jar or bottle for storage. Keep in the refrigerator to ensure freshness—it should last for several months!

Tips for Success

• Quality of Vanilla Beans Matters: High-quality beans (like Madagascar or Tahitian) will give you the best flavor, so don’t cut corners! Trader Joe’s often carries affordable vanilla bean pods if you’re shopping for quality ingredients.
• Sweetness is Optional: If you prefer a less sweet paste, reduce the sugar or omit it entirely, especially if you’re pairing the paste with recipes that are already sweet.
• Match the Consistency to Your Needs: If a recipe calls for vanilla extract, you can thin the paste slightly with water to make it easier to measure—or keep it thick for recipes like frosting or custards.
• Maximize Pods: After blending and straining (if desired), you can reuse the scraped pods by soaking them in sugar to create vanilla-infused sugar for future baking adventures!
• Test Substitutions: If you want to replicate Trader Joe’s product, experiment with invert sugar syrup or other stabilizers for that signature smoothness and longevity.

What to serve with

Trader Joe’s Vanilla Bean Paste is a versatile ingredient that adds a rich, intense vanilla flavor to a variety of recipes.

a) Baked Goods

• Vanilla Bean Cupcakes: Infuse your cake batter and frosting with vanilla bean paste for an aromatic, bakery-quality treat.
• Pound Cake: Replace vanilla extract with paste to give this dense, buttery cake an irresistible flavor boost.
• Vanilla Bean Scones: Add vanilla paste to scone dough and glaze for a flavor-packed tea-time treat. Those tiny black specks of vanilla add a rustic, artisanal touch.

b) Frostings and Fillings

• Buttercream Frosting: Mix vanilla bean paste into your frosting for extra flavor and specks that elevate the visual appeal of cakes, cookies, and cupcakes.
• Custards and Creams: Use it to flavor pastry cream, ganache, or whipped cream for desserts like éclairs, tart fillings, or trifles.

c) Frozen Treats

• Vanilla Bean Ice Cream: A simple ice cream made with just cream, sugar, eggs, and Trader Joe’s Vanilla Bean Paste can turn into a decadent centerpiece dessert.
• Milkshakes and Smoothies: A teaspoon of vanilla bean paste added to milkshakes, smoothies, or protein shakes will add a flavor depth that’s hard to beat.

d) Puddings and Custards

• Crème Brûlée: Stir vanilla bean paste into the custard base for that luxurious flavor and stunning vanilla speckles in every spoonful.
• Panna Cotta: Add it to the cream mixture of this Italian dessert for a silky-smooth finish.
• Rice Pudding: Transform basic rice pudding into a gourmet dessert with a hint of vanilla.

Ingredients Substitutes

While Trader Joe’s Vanilla Bean Paste is a convenient product, making your own at home allows customization and flexibility. Sometimes, you may not have all the traditional ingredients on hand—such as high-quality vanilla beans, specific thickeners, or sweeteners —making it challenging to achieve the desired result.

1. Vanilla Beans

Vanilla beans are the star of the recipe, providing the flavor and the appealing black flecks seen in the paste. However, high-quality whole vanilla beans (like Madagascar or Tahitian varieties) can be expensive or hard to find.

Substitutes:

• Vanilla Extract: If you don’t have vanilla beans, you can use pure vanilla extract as a substitute. While it won’t give you the signature black specks of the paste, it will still add plenty of flavor.
• Vanilla Powder: Made from dried and finely ground vanilla beans, this is an excellent alternative. It offers a concentrated flavor and the specks that mimic those from vanilla beans. Use the same amount as you would for vanilla beans or bean paste.
• Vanilla Bean Paste (Store-Bought): If you run out of one brand (like Trader Joe’s), many other brands offer pre-made vanilla bean paste. Look for options like Nielsen-Massey or a supermarket brand paste as a convenient substitute.
• Imitation Vanilla: While imitation vanilla can provide flavor, it’s less natural and nuanced compared to real vanilla. Use it as a last resort when other options aren’t available.

2. Sweetener

Sugar is often included in vanilla bean paste to balance the intense flavor and act as a preservative. If you prefer a different taste or texture or want to reduce sugar, you can try these substitutes.

Substitutes:

Honey

• For a natural alternative to sugar, use honey. It adds a slight floral sweetness that pairs well with vanilla.
• Adjust to taste, as honey is sweeter than sugar (reduce to ¾ of the amount of sugar).

Maple Syrup

• Maple syrup introduces a light caramel flavor that can complement vanilla nicely, making your paste a little warmer in tone.
• Use equal amounts to replace sugar.

Agave Syrup

• A mild, versatile liquid sweetener that works well for a paste. Agave is slightly sweeter than sugar, so adjust accordingly.

Coconut Sugar

• Coconut sugar has a toffee-like flavor that blends excellently with vanilla. Use it for a paste that’s less sweet and has an earthy profile.
• Replace in a 1:1 ratio for sugar.

Sugar-Free Options

• If you want a low-calorie substitute, try stevia, erythritol, or monk fruit sweeteners. Keep in mind these can alter the flavor slightly and may require experimentation with proportions.

3. Thickener

The iconic thick, spoonable consistency of vanilla bean paste comes from a thickening agent. Corn syrup is often used commercially, but you can easily swap it for other options depending on your preferences.

Substitutes:

• Cornstarch: The most common substitute for thickening. Dissolve in water before using to avoid clumping. Aim for 1 teaspoon per cup of liquid.
• Xanthan Gum: A powerful thickener often used in gluten-free baking. Use a very small amount (¼ teaspoon) to create a thick, syrupy consistency.
• Arrowroot Powder: Similar to cornstarch, arrowroot flour is an excellent thickening alternative, especially if you’re aiming for a gluten-free paste. It gives a clean finish without altering flavor.
• Agar-Agar: Agar-agar, a plant-based thickener, works well for creating a paste that holds its consistency. Dissolve in hot liquid before adding to your mixture.
• Glucose Syrup or Honey: If you prefer a sweeter and smoother consistency without a powdery thickener, you can use glucose syrup, honey, or agave syrup. These also act as natural preservatives.

4. Liquid Ingredients

Vanilla bean paste recipes often use a combination of water and alcohol (usually from vanilla extract) to create the right texture. If you’d like to customize the base liquid or replace alcohol, these are excellent options:

Substitutes:

• Water Only: For a simple alcohol-free recipe, you can use just water. Balance flavors by relying on the quality of your vanilla beans or extract.
• Milk or Cream: For a richer, creamier paste, substitute the water with milk or heavy cream. This is perfect for desserts like custards or ice cream bases.
• Flavor-Infused Liquids: Infuse your water or base liquid with additional flavors, such as orange zest, cinnamon, or lavender, to create a unique twist.

Final Thoughts

Trader Joe’s Vanilla Bean Paste is a culinary treasure for anyone who loves the warm, sweet flavor of vanilla.

More Trader Joe’s Recipes:

• Copycat Trader Joe’s Banana Bread Recipe
• Copycat Trader Joe’s Butternut Squash Recipe
• Copycat Trader Joe’s Maple Butter Recipe
• Copycat Trader Joe’s Soyaki Recipe